Dear Scrollers:

This week, as we celebrate the 238th anniversary of declaring American independence, our Torah cycle once again takes us to the steppe of Moab, where King Balaak employs the prophet Balaam to foretell about or march towards nationhood. We read from Balaak, Num. 22:2 - 25:5. The haftarah is Micah 5:6 - 6:8.

Though we are near the edge of the Jordan — on what can be seen as the shortest geographical distance away from fulfillment of the divine promise, we are at a place in which it will take almost 38 years to cover that distance and cross over.

In this context of contradiction and ambiguity, being so close yet so far, I ask that we consider the parable of King Balaak and the prophet Balaam: In many ways, we are being asked to ponder and consider the difference between what is seen and close — the physical presence of the promised land, the possibility of a destination and arrival — and what is far away and distant — the spiritual practice and discipline required to cross over. On one level, this portion asks us to examine the difference between external, objective boundaries and internal struggles to discern, see and accept our own shortcomings and unwillingness to follow the path that the divine has set out for us — as a group (Israelites) and as individuals.

In our discussions, I would like to focus on the following points:

1) How do we make sense of God’s conflicted and seemingly contradictory message in 22:20 -22? At first, God gives Balaam permission to go with the Moabites (v. 20) ; and when Balaam goes, God is incensed at his going (v.22).

2) What do we make of a talking ass?

3) Who sees and who doesn’t see?

4) What are the different types of vision in the parable?

5) Who leads and who follows?

6) Who obeys and who disobeys?

7) How, if at all, does the prophet Micah address these questions?

Though many, many scholars and commentators point to this portion’s blend of poetry and prose as a section of the Bible that highlights the complexities and subtleties of ancient Hebrew literature, the centerpiece remains a talking donkey who sees the angel of God.

Good shabbes.

Rick